"How far can someone go to survive, and can they truly find redemption afterward?" Moll Flanders asks readers to confront these profound questions.
1. Born Into Hardship
From her first moments, Moll Flanders faces a life of immense difficulty. She is born in Newgate Prison to a convicted felon, setting the stage for a life deeply affected by poverty and struggle. With her mother's imprisonment and eventual transportation away from England, Moll is orphaned and left to navigate a harsh world on her own.
Despite such grim beginnings, Moll shows remarkable resilience as a young child. Her early years are defined by sharp intelligence and determination. These are traits that will later help her endure the harsh realities of 17th-century life. From an early age, she displays an ability to adapt to circumstances in ways that foreshadow her adult survival strategies.
Even as a child, however, the barriers she faces reveal much about the society she lives in. Women, and especially lower-class women, have limited opportunities for independence. Moll's experiences in childhood mirror broader societal inequities, emphasizing how those born into certain circumstances often have few options in life.
Examples
- Born in prison due to her mother's criminal conviction.
- Orphaned at a young age, leaving her to fend alone.
- Raised by a foster mother, her upbringing lacks protection or privilege.
2. The Marriage Trap
For Moll, marriage isn’t just about love—it’s about survival. She understands early that, in her society, a woman's future security depends almost entirely on the man she marries. This realization drives her relentless pursuit of husbands throughout her life.
Moll's early relationships, including her coerced involvement with the older son of her employer and her eventual first marriage to Robin, underscore her limited choices. Each marriage becomes a pragmatic decision designed to provide financial and social stability. However, her unions are often fraught with betrayal, death, or even shocking revelations, such as her marriage to her half-brother in Virginia.
Through her endeavors, Defoe illustrates the limited agency women had in securing their futures. Moll’s hope for security, and the desperation it breeds, directly critiques a system that leaves few options for her gender, apart from manipulation and marriage.
Examples
- An affair with her employer's elder son leads to her first marriage with his younger brother.
- One husband runs away to escape debt, leaving her abandoned.
- She unknowingly marries her half-brother, forcing them to annul their marriage.
3. Masks and Disguises
Reinvention becomes a survival skill for Moll. Facing repeated setbacks in her search for stability, she begins adopting new names, identities, and roles to fit the moment's demands. She becomes skilled at manipulating perception, all in a bid to protect herself and find security in a hostile world.
Her ability to blend into various social circles serves her well but also leads her into morally ambiguous territories. As a self-proclaimed wealthy widow, she deceives men and even partners with acquaintances to craft elaborate false stories to elevate her status. She survives not through honesty but through her wits and charm.
Moll’s survival through disguise challenges readers to question whether morality is always possible when survival is at stake. Her shape-shifting identities reflect a society that forces individuals into pretense when the truth often denies them opportunity.
Examples
- Posing as a wealthy widow to attract potential husbands.
- With the help of an accomplice, lying about her fortune to bait a "match" in Lancashire.
- Reinventing herself to fit different economic or social situations.
4. Poverty’s Push Toward Crime
When marriage and other honest efforts fail her, Moll turns to crime as a means of survival. Living in a society that criminalizes poverty while offering little relief for the needy, she starts stealing to stay afloat. Her transformation into a thief shows both her resourcefulness and her growing moral conflicts.
Moll’s foray into theft is depicted with both cunning and desperation. She steals small items like watches and purses but later escalates to masterful acts of deception, targeting wealthier prey. These acts don’t stem from greed but from the realization that theft might be the only way to maintain her livelihood.
Through Moll’s descent into crime, Defoe critiques a society built on inequality. He portrays Moll sympathetically, not as a villain, but as a victim forced into vice by circumstance, exposing systemic flaws that leave individuals with few ethical choices for survival.
Examples
- Stealing from unsuspecting individuals on the street.
- Using disguises to enter homes and steal valuable goods.
- Becoming skilled in her criminal "trade," gaining notoriety among thieves.
5. Moral Gray Areas
Moll’s story blurs the lines between right and wrong. Her actions—deceit, theft, and manipulation—are often seen as survival mechanisms rather than outright maliciousness. Defoe portrays her as neither saint nor sinner, allowing readers to see the complexity of her choices.
This moral ambiguity invites readers to examine how societal pressures shape behavior. Moll herself reflects on her choices, often vacillating between guilt and justification. Her inner turmoil mirrors her society’s contradictions, where the wealthy are often equally unscrupulous, though more immune to punishment.
By focusing on Moll’s moral complexity, Defoe challenges readers to look beyond simple judgments. He suggests that morality is often situational and shaped by necessity, revealing nuanced humanity in even the least conventional characters.
Examples
- Reflecting on her crimes while in Newgate prison.
- Exploiting societal systems to her advantage but questioning their fairness.
- Struggling with feelings of guilt while continuing morally ambiguous actions.
6. The Cost of Survival
Surviving comes at a significant personal cost for Moll. She loses relationships, leaves children behind, and sacrifices emotional connections in the pursuit of financial and social stability. These losses highlight the toll her relentless quest for survival exacts on her.
Though Moll remarries repeatedly and bears many children, her lifestyle often forces her to abandon them. This pattern underscores how survival instincts can conflict with maternal or personal fulfillment. Moll’s story reminds readers that the measures people take to survive often involve heartbreaking compromises.
Moll’s life demonstrates how a society without safety nets punishes its vulnerable members. Her losses expose the deeply personal costs of societal inequalities that force individuals into impossible choices.
Examples
- Leaving her children with in-laws or others because of her financial struggles.
- Her failed marriage with her half-brother, which dissolves after the shocking revelation of their relationship.
- Severing ties with her lovers and children due to the pressures of her unstable circumstances.
7. Full-Circle Reckoning
Moll’s capture and imprisonment later in life serve as a turning point. Facing the gallows, she’s forced to reflect on her life, choices, and morality. Her time in Newgate Prison, where her life began, offers her a chance for self-examination and eventual change.
This moment brings Moll’s story full circle, making her confront the realities of her past while seeking redemption. Her sincere repentance, which persuades a minister to intercede on her behalf, marks a shift in her character. It hints that change, while difficult, is never impossible.
Through Moll’s reckonings, Defoe gives her the opportunity to reclaim her humanity despite her transgressions. This reflects broader themes about forgiveness and the possibility of redemption, even for those with complicated pasts.
Examples
- Captured after attempting to steal from a house.
- Imprisoned in the same jail where she was born.
- Convincing a minister of her repentance, leading to her transportation to the Colonies.
8. A Second Chance
Transportation to the Colonies marks a new chapter for Moll. In Virginia, she inherits land through her estranged son, giving her a chance to leave her criminal past behind and live a life of honesty. This fresh start signifies a hard-won redemption.
Moll’s reunion with her husband, Jemy, solidifies her path toward a simpler, happier life. The inheritance from her mother allows her to establish stability, something she has long sought. By turning over her inheritance to her son, Moll also finds peace in reconnecting with her family.
This final act demonstrates that change is possible at any stage in life. Moll’s story closes with her achieving the quiet stability she longed for, though it took decades of struggle to get there.
Examples
- Reuniting with Jemy in Newgate and reconciling their relationship.
- Discovering her inheritance and making her son her heir.
- Settling into a life of penitence and peace at age 69.
9. Morality in a Flawed Society
Moll Flanders explores how individuals navigate morality in an unforgiving social structure. Moll’s life underscores the idea that survival often leads people to make morally questionable choices, challenging the binary of good versus evil.
Defoe critiques a hypocritical society whose systems force Moll into her choices. Women like her face economic dependency, legal systems that criminalize poverty, and limited opportunities for upward mobility. Moll’s life illustrates how systemic failures often leave individuals no choice but to break rules.
The novel asks readers to reflect on the broader forces shaping Moll’s actions. By showing her humanity and resourcefulness, Defoe invites empathy and challenges simplistic judgments of morality.
Examples
- The reliance on marriage for women’s financial security.
- Moll’s descent into crime as a reaction to societal neglect.
- Society’s harsh punishments for the poor and vulnerable, as seen in Newgate Prison.
Takeaways
- Reflect on how circumstances shape morality, and strive to empathize with others’ choices.
- Understand the societal systems that perpetuate inequality and advocate for fairness in policies and practices.
- Resilience is a powerful tool; adapt when challenges arise, but don’t lose sight of self-reflection and personal growth.