Book cover of Some Assembly Required by Neil Shubin

Neil Shubin

Some Assembly Required Summary

Reading time icon11 min readRating icon4.1 (2,395 ratings)

“What do your lungs, a salamander’s tongue, and a sea squirt have in common? The twists of evolution and the surprising links of DNA answer this question in stunning ways.”

1. Old Traits, New Tricks

Plants and animals evolve by repurposing existing traits rather than growing entirely new features. This concept traces back to Charles Darwin's observations.

For instance, the shift from fins to legs that enabled fish to walk on land was not a sudden transformation. Researchers have found evidence in Egyptian fish with proto-lungs, air sacs initially developed for buoyancy but later adapted for breathing. This adaptation occurred long before fish ever stepped onto land.

Additionally, the genes responsible for building swim bladders in fish are closely linked to the genes that create lungs in humans and other land animals. This discovery has reshaped our understanding of how seemingly distinct features are deeply connected by evolution.

Examples

  • Proto-lungs observed in certain Egyptian fish.
  • Swim bladder and lung gene similarities in fish and humans.
  • Evolutionary studies showing early air-breathing capabilities in water-bound organisms.

2. Embryos Carry Clues

Embryonic development uncovers key secrets about how species evolve, as demonstrated by the Mexican salamander in the 1800s.

French scientist Auguste Duméril's investigation revealed that one salamander species could develop in two distinct ways depending on environmental conditions. Those growing in water developed fins and webbed feet, while those in dry environments grew terrestrial traits. This dual pathway highlighted the environment's role in shaping genetic expression.

Even less glamorous creatures like the sea squirt show how evolutionary ancestors adapted early on. Juvenile sea squirts retain characteristics like nerve cords that later became essential features in all vertebrates, including humans.

Examples

  • Salamanders adapting based on wet or dry environments.
  • Sea squirt’s transformation from tadpole-like embryo to rock-bound adult.
  • Discoveries linking embryonic traits to vertebrate development.

3. Small Genome Errors, Big Changes

Evolution often hinges on tiny DNA malfunctions, which can lead to significant changes in how species develop over time.

DNA, composed of intricate sequences of amino acids, relies on "switches" to control when and where genetic instructions are activated. A minor irregularity in these switches can lead to drastic outcomes. For instance, just one amino acid difference causes sickle-cell anemia, while other genetic changes can tweak traits vital to evolution, such as limb formation.

Scientists have linked alterations in genomic switches to revolutionary transformations, like the evolution from fins to wings. These changes, while small, drive the big leaps in species' abilities.

Examples

  • Single amino acid changes linked to disease like sickle-cell anemia.
  • The role of switches in creating limbs or fins.
  • Genetic differences between humans and sea squirts determined by genome switches.

4. Mutations as Nature’s Experiments

Genetic mutations provide the raw material for evolution, adjusting traits or adding entirely new ones.

Darwin viewed mutations simply as ordinary differences that occasionally gave some individuals an advantage. In modern science, we see that mutations also affect the size and form of features. For example, studies on fruit flies reveal that our genes follow a top-down layout—a shared feature that extends to frogs, humans, and even worms.

Another major discovery is how limb-building genes in fish and frogs share the same mechanisms. These genes, whether producing fins or flippers, provide insights into how mutations transform creatures across generations.

Examples

  • Mutation studies in fruit flies illuminating DNA layouts.
  • Shared limb-growth genes in vastly different species.
  • Mutated genes granting evolutionary advantages or physical differences.

5. Jumping Genes Shape DNA

The human genome is a battleground where jumping genes compete and cooperate in unexpected ways.

Jumping genes not only copy themselves but also relocate within the genome, leaving traits and alterations in their path. Barbara McClintock discovered that 70% of the human genome consists of these dynamic segments. Despite their chaotic behavior, jumping genes are controlled by defensive mechanisms within DNA, preventing harmful mutations.

This interplay between order and chaos reveals that genetic activity drives both creativity and survival in evolution.

Examples

  • Jumping genes comprise around 70% of the human genome.
  • Mechanisms in ordinary DNA preventing unchecked jumping.
  • Copied genes gaining new functions, influencing features like vision or brain development.

6. Evolution Repeatedly Solves Challenges Similarly

Nature has a limited toolkit for solving problems, so evolution often arrives at the same outcomes multiple times.

Salamanders with projectile tongues exemplify this. Despite evolving independently in separate salamander species, their adaptations fulfill similar needs. Likewise, flying creatures all depend on wings for lift because physical constraints dictate these solutions.

Recurrent solutions show that evolution is not random but guided by shared genetic elements and environmental needs.

Examples

  • Independent evolution of projectile tongues in salamanders.
  • Limited solutions for flight, like wings versus other hypothetical structures.
  • Repeated use of common genes to form traits across different species.

7. The Genetic Material Balance

Plants like corn paradoxically have more genetic material than humans, proving complexity doesn’t correlate to DNA quantity.

Much of an organism’s DNA is considered “junk,” leftover from earlier evolutionary stages. However, even junk DNA may serve hidden purposes, such as preserving unused traits or contributing to genetic variation when needed.

Examples

  • Corn with twice the genetic material of humans.
  • “Junk” DNA offering insights into genetic history.
  • Examples of animals retaining seemingly dormant traits.

8. Early Organisms Paved the Way

Billions of years ago, single-celled organisms unknowingly set life on Earth in motion by introducing oxygen into the atmosphere.

Their gradual teamwork with other microbes resulted in advanced energy systems, allowing multicellular organisms to flourish. This cooperation was a fundamental chapter in biological history, showing that life as we know it stemmed from these primitive beginnings.

Examples

  • Single-celled creatures producing oxygen.
  • Microbes teaming up to create complex proteins.
  • The development of multicellular life stemming from collaborative microbes.

9. Evolution’s Path May Have Been Destined

Despite evolution’s chaos, some outcomes—like flight or limbs—were statistical certainties given the limits of biology and environment.

Traits like salamanders’ tongues or birds’ wings show that nature continuously lands on similar fixes for recurring problems. This repeatability highlights genetics and physical forces’ powerful influence on shaping life’s trajectory.

Examples

  • Wings evolving similarly in birds, bats, and insects.
  • Independent origins of salamanders’ fast tongues.
  • Consistent genetic solutions across unrelated species.

Takeaways

  1. Consider how small changes in your environment or habits can lead to significant growth or transformation over time, just as in evolution.
  2. Explore connections between seemingly unrelated phenomena—they might share underlying principles, similar to genetic links between species.
  3. Take inspiration from nature’s adaptability; repurpose resources or ideas for new challenges instead of discarding them.

Books like Some Assembly Required