Book cover of Dealing with China by Henry M. Paulson

Henry M. Paulson

Dealing with China

Reading time icon12 min readRating icon3.8 (1,494 ratings)

How did a country like China, rooted in communist principles, transform into one of the world’s largest economies in just a few decades? Dealing with China unveils the methods, challenges, and implications of this epic transformation.

1. Opening Up the Economy Accelerated Growth

In the late 1970s, China was an impoverished nation with a stagnant, centralized economy. The turning point came after Mao Zedong's death, when Deng Xiaoping introduced a wave of market-oriented reforms. These reforms sought to integrate China into the global market by adopting western economic practices.

The foundation of these changes was allowing state-owned enterprises (SOEs) greater control over their operations. SOEs could sell their goods and services at market prices, enabling them to operate more flexibly. Additionally, the creation of Special Economic Zones (SEZs) encouraged entrepreneurship by offering tax incentives and fewer trade restrictions, drawing foreign investments and nurturing Chinese businesses.

The results were breathtaking. By the 1980s, China saw its GDP grow at an average annual rate of 10%. Hundreds of millions were lifted out of poverty, and young entrepreneurs sprouted across the country, sparking a remarkable period of innovation and economic activity.

Examples

  • SEZs became innovation hotspots, driving the success of companies like Lenovo and Hangzhou Wahaha Group.
  • SOEs improved in efficiency by operating in semi-market systems, completing planned government quotas while pursuing profits.
  • Foreign investment poured in, providing technology, knowledge, and capital to modernize industries.

2. The Telecom Sector’s Privatization Sparked Modernization

Privatizing the telecom industry marked a significant step toward reshaping China's economy. By the early 1990s, China's inefficient telecom system was crippling its modernization efforts. Inspired by global deregulation examples like Deutsche Telekom, China decided to privatize its telecom services by selling shares to the public.

Between 1992 and 1996, massive investments in infrastructure saw telephone line connections multiply. However, inefficiencies persisted, burdening SOEs with debt. When China Telecom was privatized through an IPO in 1997, it raised over $4.2 billion — double initial expectations. By introducing private investors and competition, the government drastically improved service delivery and drove faster technological advancements.

Thanks to such efforts, China emerged as a telecommunications leader, with multiple national carriers competing to elevate service standards and coverage by 2008.

Examples

  • Telecom privatization raised billions, demonstrating the success of market-driven approaches.
  • Competitive carriers like China Mobile emerged, creating efficiency improvements and technological growth.
  • Networks expanded rapidly, going from 11.5 million fixed-line connections in 1992 to over 55 million by 1996.

3. Reshaping the Oil Industry Required Sacrifice

Privatizing China's deeply inefficient oil industry was immensely challenging, as companies were burdened with excessive employees and outdated processes. The giant China National Petroleum Company (CNPC) exemplified inefficiency, employing over 1.5 million workers — far beyond industry needs.

Rebranding CNPC as PetroChina meant cutting costs. Layoffs became inevitable, with hundreds of thousands dismissed to attract foreign investors and restructure operations. The process faced widespread backlash, including protests from affected workers. Despite these struggles, PetroChina became more competitive on the global stage.

Though transformative, this reform highlighted the human toll of China's rapid economic modernization, as countless employees faced unemployment and uncertain futures.

Examples

  • PetroChina's IPO raised the company's global profile despite major protests.
  • The 1999 restructuring reduced CNPC's workforce by two-thirds.
  • China’s state-owned sector shed 40 million jobs between 1990 and 2001.

4. Banking and Education Reforms Enabled Global Competition

China's outdated banking sector and rigid education system posed major obstacles to engaging with global markets. Banking institutions struggled under the weight of bad loans to failing SOEs, while universities focused on theoretical knowledge, failing to produce skilled business managers.

Premier Zhu Rongji tackled these problems head-on by piloting executive education reforms at Tsinghua University and modernizing banking structures. New business education models based on case studies trained over 50,000 entrepreneurs, while state-backed banks underwent stringent clean-ups. Over $135 billion in bad loans were written off to strengthen the banking framework and reduce economic risks.

These reforms equipped China with a pool of talented managers and established healthier, globally competitive financial systems.

Examples

  • Tsinghua University revamped its curriculum to emphasize hands-on learning through case studies.
  • In a six-year effort, China’s largest bank, ICBC, eliminated $135 billion in toxic loans.
  • Four major state-owned banks were restructured, encouraging competition for better performance.

5. Rising Debt Poses Serious Risks

As China's economy expanded, so did its debt. Rapid borrowing, particularly after the 2008 global financial crisis, caused debt levels to jump from 130% of GDP in 2008 to 206% by 2014. While fueling growth, this debt outpaced GDP growth, creating a ticking economic time bomb.

China must delink political controls from SOEs to create commercially viable systems. Unless reforms allow SOEs full independence to manage debt and compete in markets, the entire economy could face destabilization.

International experts, including the IMF, have flagged these trends as warning signals. Failure to address debt growth risks pushing China into an economic meltdown that could disrupt global markets.

Examples

  • The IMF publicly warned China about its surging debt in 2014.
  • SOEs remain under heavy political influence, limiting market-driven decision-making.
  • Debt surpassed 206% of GDP in 2014, signaling unsustainable borrowing patterns.

6. Pollution Demands Immediate Responses

China’s rapid industrialization has severely harmed its environment. The air pollution in Beijing exceeds hazardous limits, while widespread contamination of water bodies has left many regions with undrinkable water.

Investments in cleaner energy technologies have become unavoidable. Institutions like the Paulson Institute are collaborating with Chinese policymakers to promote sustainability, protect biodiversity, and train officials in urban development techniques.

Addressing environmental degradation is necessary, not only for China's progress but for global ecological stability.

Examples

  • The Paulson Institute provided training programs for cities to achieve urban sustainability.
  • Beijing’s air pollution regularly exceeds U.S. hazard standards.
  • Groundwater depletion in China’s northern regions poses serious water stress.

7. Communication Strengthened US-China Ties

Open communication increasingly helped ease tensions between the US and China. The creation of the Strategic Economic Dialogue (SED) in 2006 marked a new era of cooperation. For the first time, Chinese and US officials met as a unified delegation to discuss economic issues.

This approach eliminated earlier communication gaps, where various U.S. departments delivered mixed signals. The SED enabled breakthroughs like expanding flight agreements and opening Nasdaq offices in China, reflecting trust-building efforts.

Discussion and collaboration proved essential in managing economic relationships and addressing shared challenges.

Examples

  • The 2006 SED saw China reopen negotiations on US airline routes.
  • Regulators authorized the Nasdaq’s and NYSE’s presence in China’s markets.
  • Collaborative talks bridged longstanding trade-related disagreements.

8. Collaboration with China Benefits the US

Americans often question the rationale for supporting China, a global economic competitor. Yet China’s challenges, such as pollution and sustainability, directly impact the US. For instance, airborne pollution from China contributes significantly to smog on the US west coast.

Mutual investments deliver benefits, from job creation in America to profits for Chinese firms. Companies such as Wanxiang stabilized bankrupt US businesses during the financial crisis, saving thousands of American jobs.

Building partnerships with China is a long-term strategy that addresses shared challenges while harnessing opportunities for growth.

Examples

  • Wanxiang’s investment in US auto parts manufacturers secured over 3,500 American jobs.
  • Chinese investment in the US grew to $14 billion by 2013 across diverse industries.
  • A study linked 25% of West Coast sulfate pollution to Chinese factories.

9. China’s Growth Requires Sustainable Reforms

China’s rise has been extraordinary, but maintaining that momentum depends on sustainable practices. Beyond environmental impacts, the government must resolve systemic inefficiencies in SOEs, reduce mounting debt, and rely more on market forces.

Collaboration with international stakeholders remains key to navigating these domestic reforms while balancing global geopolitical tensions.

China’s continued growth offers both challenges and opportunities, emphasizing the need for shared responsibilities in the global economic system.

Examples

  • Environmental investments could reduce Beijing’s choking smog levels.
  • Greater SOE independence would improve efficiency and encourage innovation.
  • Sustainable collaborations, such as the Paulson Institute’s efforts, offer scalable solutions.

Takeaways

  1. Encourage collaborative relationships between nations to solve global challenges, from economic instability to environmental sustainability.
  2. Recognize the potential benefits of mutual investment in generating growth, jobs, and innovation across borders.
  3. Support efforts to nurture education and development reforms, enabling economies to adapt to modern global landscapes.

Books like Dealing with China