What happens when a thriving town built on the promise of the American Dream succumbs to the forces of unchecked greed and corporate exploitation?

1. Lancaster’s Rise: A Town Built on Community and Hard Work

Lancaster, Ohio once epitomized the classic American small town, offering stability and pride for its working-class residents. Central to Lancaster’s success was the Anchor Hocking Glass Company, which employed thousands and gave purpose to its community. Workers knew they had a secure future, and families thrived on decency and togetherness.

Anchor Hocking was more than just a factory—it was the heartbeat of the town. Workers would often graduate high school and seamlessly transition into factory roles, beginning long and fulfilling careers. The factory wasn’t separated from the community; executives drank at the same bars as factory workers, friendships crossed lines of class, and residents felt connected to the company that sustained them.

The town operated on a sense of trust and mutual respect. Families lived modest but worry-free lives because the local economy rewarded labor and loyalty. Women led social causes, kept schools running, and created opportunities for civic advancement, while men earned steady wages and retirement security through their factory jobs.

Examples

  • High school graduates stepping straight into lifelong careers at Anchor Hocking.
  • Anchor executives socializing with workers in local taverns.
  • Community projects led by residents, from repairing sidewalks to fighting for new schools.

2. Lancaster’s Sharp Decline: A Town Stuck in Crisis

The once-thriving town of Lancaster has since crumbled into unemployment, addiction, and despair. With factories abandoned, homes deteriorating, and families broken, Lancaster’s picturesque facade has faded into a burdensome reality.

Opiate addiction plagued the town, affecting families across generations. Social service programs in the surrounding counties juggled the care of children whose parents were addicts. Residents who had once laughed together at football games now faced arrest from lifelong friends tasked with enforcing the law.

Though the town seemed outwardly destroyed by a failing economy and rampant drug culture, much of the struggle was rooted in systemic shortcomings. Moral blame was often placed on the people enduring Lancaster’s collapse, but the negligence and greed that triggered the downfall were rarely acknowledged.

Examples

  • Fairfield County reporting that 58 percent of children in social services had parents struggling with opioid addiction.
  • Dilapidated and abandoned homes dotting the once-beautiful streets of Lancaster.
  • A police officer breaking into tears while arresting former classmates for drug-related crimes.

3. Corporations Turned Communities Into Commodities

Decisions by businessmen far removed from Lancaster transformed a respected local factory into a pawn for profiteering. Lancaster’s story highlights how private investors treated the factory as mere capital, ignoring its ties to the town.

Starting in the 1980s, financiers like Carl Icahn began leveraging the company purely for financial gain. Using tactics such as “greenmailing,” corporate raiders forced Anchor Hocking to buy back stock at inflated prices, leaving the company less stable. Rather than reinvest in its facilities or employees, the company became a revolving door for investment firms, each taking its cut.

With every buyout, key Lancaster executives were fired, pensions were chipped away, and union demands were ignored. The company turned from a town cornerstone into just another struggling name stripped of its ability to innovate or care for its workforce.

Examples

  • Carl Icahn pocketing millions by exploiting Anchor Hocking’s stock during a takeover.
  • Factory operations being relocated to Tampa, dismantling local employment in Lancaster.
  • Benefits like company pensions disappearing under every successive corporate owner.

4. Free Market Policies Set the Stage for Financial Exploitation

The unregulated capitalism of the 1980s, encouraged by the Reagan administration, created opportunities for private raiders and bad leadership. By prioritizing profits over sustainability, Lancaster’s stability eroded under free-market manipulation.

Politicians painted deregulation as a way to strengthen the American economy, but the reality brought devastation to working-class towns. Once regulation was minimized, outsiders found ways to extract money from firms without adding value. Anchor Hocking’s profits evaporated under manipulative schemes like leveraged buyouts, which left the company drowning in debt.

This cultural shift didn’t just affect businesses but reshaped communities. CEOs and executives moved corporate headquarters elsewhere, disconnecting from struggling towns and depriving them of local investments, taxes, and leadership.

Examples

  • Ronald Reagan’s economic policies removing corporate regulations in the 1980s.
  • Investment firms flipping Anchor Hocking for profit, removing local leadership with each sale.
  • Tax breaks given to companies draining local schools of needed funding.

5. The Toll of Corporate Buyouts: Broken Promises and Lives

When investors took over Anchor Hocking, local workers faced difficult choices that fractured Lancaster socially and economically. Executives made heartless decisions that prioritized quick payouts over the company’s health or its employees' livelihoods.

Severance packages dwindled, retirement plans transformed into uncertain 401(k)s, and once-guaranteed futures became precarious. With costs cut at every turn, Lancaster’s lifeblood, its factory, aged into irrelevance. For workers, this meant less job security, lower wages, and little acknowledgment of past loyalty.

The town’s residents grew vulnerable, watching as generations lost the assurances of their predecessors. Anchor Hocking, once a cherished symbol of reliability, became a reminder of missed opportunities and exploited trust.

Examples

  • Lancaster laborers facing steep wage cuts under each buyout contract.
  • Executives privatizing pensions without safeguarding workers’ retirement funds.
  • The gradual obsolescence of Anchor Hocking machinery due to budget neglect.

6. A Misplaced Blame on Lancaster’s Residents

Some outsiders, including pundits like Kevin D. Williamson, have scapegoated Lancaster’s residents for the town’s undoing, branding them as lazy or complicit. This perspective ignores decades of structural disadvantages the town endured.

Chronic addiction, joblessness, or crumbling infrastructure are symptoms of larger disasters. For 35 years, Lancaster residents bore the brunt of self-serving financiers hollowing out their economy. These circumstances created frustration and mistrust—conditions some media outlets misinterpreted as moral failing.

People don’t crumble from laziness but from sustained deprivation of opportunities. Lancaster’s fate centers not on its people’s character, but on a system prioritizing wealth over lives.

Examples

  • Williamson’s comments reducing Lancaster’s downfall to “white working-class selfishness.”
  • The removal of corporate taxes, downsizing civic budgets.
  • Media narratives wrongly tying local problems solely to drug addiction.

7. The Town’s Political Shift Toward Donald Trump

Lancaster voters overwhelmingly supported Donald Trump’s presidency, hoping to embrace promises of restored jobs and traditional values. The despair that drove much of the vote stemmed from economic and social erosion.

Ohio, a swing state, played a critical role in electing Trump, largely due to Midwestern towns like Lancaster. The region’s anger boiled over decades of loss—vanished pensions, gutted schools, and diminished pride. Many clung to leaders who promised a brighter future.

While their vote might be tied to restoring identity, it also ignored the irony—Trump’s affiliated systems, from free-market capitalism to consigliere Carl Icahn, contributed directly to Lancaster’s struggles.

Examples

  • Trump carrying 61 percent of Lancaster’s Fairfield County in the 2016 election.
  • Lancaster’s collapse providing an example of why swing-state frustrations affect election outcomes.
  • Voters grappling with decades of structural failure.

8. Misguided Loyalty to Harmful Economic Ideals

Ironically, Lancaster residents still praise Reagan-like policies upheld by thinkers like Milton Friedman, despite these being the foundations of their town's struggles. By clinging to outdated ideals of free-market invulnerability, they miss the destructive consequences.

Politicians exploiting ideals of freedom encouraged deregulation that gutted local resources, justifying underinvestment in public services and transferring wealth back toward isolated executive elites. Lancaster reflects this contradiction: a town still sold on the false hope of policies that ultimately betrayed them.

Examples

  • Midwestern residents, including Lancaster, championing free-market heroes despite economic breakdowns.
  • Deregulatory policies praised even as factories like Anchor Hocking shuttered.
  • Striking similarities between pre-1980s Lancaster stability and the devastation after deregulation.

9. Structural Despair in Towns Across America

Lancaster is only one story in a national trend of American towns losing out. Its rise and fall represent broader concerns for communities heavily affected by corporate tactics exploiting resources until fallout becomes irreparable.

Understanding Lancaster means grappling with the broader idea that many American systems no longer prioritize people or places. It also beckons an examination of what policies could restore jobs, rebuild civic trust, and prevent future communities from suffering Lancaster’s plight.

Examples

  • Comparisons of Lancaster with other devastated factory towns, especially in swing states.
  • Firms like Monomoy Capital Partners operating similarly across hundreds of American facilities.
  • National shifts in small-town despair during large elections (e.g., 2016).

Takeaways

  1. Question the long-term impact of free-market policies before glorifying immediate benefits—short-term gains can devastate futures.
  2. Advocate for policies holding private equity firms accountable for their treatment of town-based economies.
  3. Support investigative journalism that uncovers hidden exploitation in towns facing similar struggles to Lancaster.

Books like Glass House