Book cover of I Shouldn't Feel This Way by Alison Cook

I Shouldn't Feel This Way

by Alison Cook

9 min readRating: 4.5 (182 ratings)
Genres
Buy full book on Amazon

In today's fast-paced world, it's easy to lose touch with our emotions and neglect our mental health. Alison Cook's book, "I Shouldn't Feel This Way," offers a compassionate guide to navigating complex emotions and developing a healthier relationship with ourselves and others. This summary will explore the key ideas presented in the book, providing practical tools and insights to help you on your journey towards emotional resilience and personal growth.

Introduction: The Importance of Emotional Awareness

We often find ourselves caught in a whirlwind of daily responsibilities, social obligations, and endless distractions. In this chaotic environment, it's no wonder that we frequently push aside our own well-being and ignore the signals our emotions are sending us. Cook's book serves as a beacon, guiding us towards a more mindful approach to our inner lives.

The author introduces a powerful process called "Name. Frame. Brave." This method helps us to identify our emotions, understand their context, and take courageous steps towards positive change. By implementing these strategies, we can overcome feelings of inadequacy, navigate toxic relationships, and address spiritual conflicts that may be holding us back.

Naming the Hard Feelings

One of the first steps in emotional growth is learning to recognize and acknowledge our difficult emotions. Many of us have a tendency to push away uncomfortable feelings, responding with guilt or trying to force ourselves to "toughen up" or "be more grateful." However, this approach often leads to a cycle of inner turmoil and self-criticism.

Cook suggests a different path: treating our inner turmoil as a signal to pause and reflect. Instead of beating ourselves up for having these feelings, we can create space for clarity and action by being curious about our emotions and accepting them as they are.

The "Name. Frame. Brave." process begins with naming what's hard. This involves:

  1. Paying attention to your inner experiences
  2. Validating your emotions
  3. Identifying triggers for particular feelings
  4. Labeling your emotions accurately (e.g., lonely, burned-out, anxious)

One helpful practice for naming your emotions is journaling. By writing down your experiences, you can gain clarity about what's triggering your feelings and how they're affecting you. This honest acknowledgment is the first step towards transforming inner turmoil into brave steps for a more fulfilling life.

Giving Yourself Space to Reframe

The second step in Cook's method is framing your reality. This takes place in what she calls "the in-between" – a space where you step back and give yourself time to process your emotions and gain a better understanding of your situation.

Think of this as a detox from stress, allowing your mind to unwind and untangle. This period of reflection can take many forms:

  • Spending time in a familiar, comforting environment
  • Engaging in quiet daily rituals like a peaceful walk or commute
  • Creating small pockets of time for introspection

Once you've granted yourself this space, the art of framing involves moving from the immediate "what" of your situation to the deeper "why." Cook introduces the FRAME process to help with this:

  1. Facts: Clarify the reality of the situation
  2. Roots: Reflect on deeper motives and past experiences
  3. Audit: Review past strategies and assess their effectiveness
  4. Mental Messages: Reexamine your thoughts and self-expectations
  5. Expansion: Broaden your understanding through research and conversations

This process helps you gain perspective and see a way forward. It allows you to let go of old coping mechanisms that no longer serve you and gather confidence for new paths.

Moving Beyond Inner Conflict

As you gain clarity about your emotions, you may uncover various forms of inner conflict. One common issue is cognitive dissonance – a disconnect between your beliefs and actions. This can manifest in subtle ways, like enjoying time with a friend and then speaking negatively about them behind their back.

When you notice this inner conflict:

  1. Name it
  2. Frame it by asking what triggers these patterns
  3. Reflect on how you'd like to change
  4. Offer yourself the same compassion you'd give a loved one

Another common challenge is the tendency to numb our emotions. This might involve excessive scrolling on your phone, emotional eating, or unnecessary shopping. While numbing might provide temporary relief, it often leads to bigger problems in the long run.

To address numbing behaviors:

  1. Identify if a behavior is disrupting essential needs or feels compulsive
  2. Name the emotions associated with the behavior without shame
  3. Frame the behavior by understanding when and why you numb
  4. Explore alternative coping strategies

Cook suggests various forms of care to replace numbing behaviors:

  • Relational care (talking with friends or family)
  • Sensory care (listening to music or enjoying nature)
  • Recreational care (gardening or painting)
  • Physical care (exercise and deep breathing)
  • Spiritual care (praying or meditating)

By taking these mindful steps, you can find healthier ways to cope with your emotions and break the cycle of numbing.

The Conflict Between Body and Mind

Our relationship with our bodies is often complicated. Many of us view our physical selves as burdens, leading to feelings of shame and frustration. To change this perspective, Cook suggests reframing how we think about our bodies:

  1. Consider the facts: What were you taught about your body, and where did these messages come from?
  2. Reflect on the roots: Why does your view of your body matter?
  3. Audit your experiences: When have you felt connected to your body in a healthy way versus times of shame or frustration?
  4. Examine mental messages: What do you tell yourself about your body?
  5. Expand your thinking: Explore various spiritual and scientific perspectives on the human body

To brave embodiment means truly tuning into your body's needs. This might involve:

  • Moving around or stretching when you feel tense
  • Drinking water when you're thirsty
  • Dancing to your favorite song to boost your mood

The goal is to work with your body rather than against it, recognizing when it needs rest, nourishment, or movement. This reciprocal relationship can help regulate emotions and provide clarity and strength.

Another common challenge in our digital age is getting stuck in comparisons. While some comparison can be motivating, too much often leads to lowered self-esteem and increased depression. To combat this:

  1. Name your inner critic
  2. Recognize comparison triggers
  3. Explore more effective ways to motivate yourself

Building self-confidence goes hand-in-hand with moving away from comparisons. Try these strategies:

  • Identify your strengths and talents
  • Seek input from trusted friends or coworkers
  • Take steps to advance your skills
  • Practice gratitude by listing things you're proud of each day

By addressing how you view your body and handle comparisons, you can foster a healthier, more confident relationship with yourself.

Navigating Relationships: The Highs and Lows

As we move from internal conflicts to external ones, it's important to address toxicity in relationships. In healthy relationships, people take responsibility for their mistakes and make amends. However, toxic behaviors like control, manipulation, blame-shifting, and gaslighting can disrupt this process and leave you feeling trapped and confused.

To combat toxicity in relationships:

  1. Name the toxic behaviors and their impact on you
  2. Reflect on when the behavior started and how often it occurs
  3. Notice how you feel after interactions with the person
  4. Set clear boundaries and limits

If you can't leave a toxic relationship (e.g., co-parenting situations), try these strategies:

  • Stick to written communication when possible
  • Set time limits and choose public places for interactions
  • Agree on a list of neutral topics for discussions

Maintaining faith in yourself and the process can be challenging during difficult times. Cook warns against what she calls "counterfeit messages" – misguided beliefs like thinking we deserve suffering or that we wouldn't be suffering if we had more faith. It's important to remember that faith doesn't guarantee a problem-free life, and minimizing past hurts can actually make forgiveness more difficult.

To address counterfeit messages:

  1. Identify the messages you've held onto
  2. Reflect on their origins and whether they're a positive influence
  3. Do research and talk to different people
  4. Tap into spiritual communities for support and healing

These communities can provide safe spaces to express difficult feelings without judgment and foster connection and transformation.

Final Thoughts: Embracing the Journey

The key message of "I Shouldn't Feel This Way" is that there are no shortcuts to understanding and managing complex emotions. While it's natural to want to numb ourselves or push away difficult feelings, the path to growth and healing lies in naming, framing, and braving our emotions as they arise.

By implementing the strategies outlined in this book, you can:

  1. Become more attuned to your body's needs
  2. Set healthy boundaries in toxic relationships
  3. Embrace your talents without succumbing to societal pressures
  4. Transform emotional pain into personal growth and spiritual resilience

Remember that this is a journey, and it's okay to take small steps. Be patient with yourself as you learn to navigate your emotions and develop a more compassionate relationship with yourself and others. With time and practice, you'll find yourself better equipped to handle life's challenges and more in touch with your authentic self.

As you move forward on this path of self-discovery and emotional well-being, keep in mind that setbacks are normal. Don't be discouraged if you find yourself falling back into old patterns occasionally. The important thing is to keep trying, to be kind to yourself, and to celebrate the progress you make along the way.

By embracing the process of naming, framing, and braving your emotions, you're taking an important step towards a more fulfilling and authentic life. As you continue to practice these skills, you'll likely find that you're better able to navigate complex emotions, build stronger relationships, and approach life's challenges with greater resilience and self-awareness.

In conclusion, "I Shouldn't Feel This Way" offers a compassionate and practical approach to emotional well-being. By acknowledging our feelings, understanding their context, and taking brave steps forward, we can transform our inner turmoil into opportunities for growth and healing. As you apply these principles in your own life, remember that every small step counts, and that you're not alone on this journey towards a more emotionally balanced and fulfilling life.

Books like I Shouldn't Feel This Way