Book cover of Scaling Down by Judi Culbertson

Judi Culbertson

Scaling Down

Reading time icon12 min readRating icon3.6 (267 ratings)

Do you really need all that stuff to be happy, or could fewer belongings lead to a freer, more fulfilled life?

1. The Origins of Hoarding

Hoarding tendencies stem from historical experiences like the Great Depression. This era ingrained the habit of saving, as people held on to anything that might be useful in the future.

Even after the economy recovered, this mindset was passed down through generations. Families continued to stockpile items out of fear of scarcity. Today, that ingrained habit manifests as overstuffed closets and endless knick-knacks.

The modern world amplifies this tendency with constant advertising, persuading people to buy more than they need. What was once a survival skill now makes modern homes cluttered and stressful to manage.

Examples

  • Families impacted by the Great Depression routinely saved buttons, jars, and tins for "what if" scenarios.
  • Marketing campaigns encourage consumers to buy "the newest model" of items they already own.
  • People renting external storage spaces for items they rarely access.

2. The Power of a Mission Statement

A Scaling Down Mission Statement (SDMS) helps identify and focus your reasons for decluttering, making the process feel purposeful.

Crafting an SDMS can involve a single sentence or just a few keywords that express your goal. It might be as straightforward as “make space for a home office” or “prepare for downsizing.” By defining your motivation, you set the tone for the entire process.

Having a clear goal reduces the overwhelm of sorting through years of belongings. It transforms the effort into an intentional act and gives you a sense of accomplishment as you progress.

Examples

  • Someone helping a relative downsize into assisted living might use the SDMS, “Keep only what truly matters for my aunt.”
  • Writing “simple living” on a sticky note can serve as a constant reminder while decluttering.
  • Parents clearing a nursery after their child has grown might frame their effort as “make way for new stages in life.”

3. Apprehensions About Letting Go

The fear of making a mistake often makes people hesitate to declutter. Many worry they might throw away something they could regret later.

However, most forgotten items lie untouched for a reason—they lack real utility or bring little joy. Getting over this fear requires recognizing that if you haven't used something in years, you’re unlikely to use it in the future.

Initially, the process may feel daunting, especially regarding sentimental items. A strategy to ease this fear is setting a timeframe; if you haven’t needed an item after a few months, give yourself permission to let it go.

Examples

  • Someone throwing out old meeting agendas can realize they never looked at them in years.
  • A parent storing their child’s outgrown sports gear may eventually donate it after months without missing it.
  • Setting a rule like “If it stays unused for five years, it must go” can help streamline decisions.

4. Rethinking Collections

Large collections can overwhelm a living space without adding value. Consider transitioning to smaller or non-physical collections that are easier to manage or even invisible.

Traditional collectors often focus on records, books, or toys. While these bring joy initially, they can quickly grow uncontrollable. Instead, options like stamps or digital collections occupying minimal physical space may be more practical.

Another creative approach is collecting experiences instead. Activities like birdwatching, travel, or photography allow "collecting" without ever crowding your home.

Examples

  • A record collector downsizes by digitizing rare albums into a high-quality archive.
  • Instead of acquiring expensive objects, a globetrotter "collects" memories by visiting 25 new countries.
  • A budding bird enthusiast documents sighting new species rather than accumulating physical objects.

5. Grouping for Clarity

The act of grouping similar items helps create order and reveal hidden redundancies, making it easier to identify what’s unnecessary.

Start by gathering duplicates of a single category, like kitchen utensils or shoes. Seeing everything side by side lets you make objective decisions about what to keep and what to donate or discard.

Grouping also exposes excesses that might otherwise stay hidden. That realization helps evaluate needs versus wants more critically.

Examples

  • A person reducing their wardrobe groups 15 identical black T-shirts, deciding to keep only the three in best condition.
  • Sorting all umbrellas in a household reveals more than enough backups for rainy days.
  • Grouping sports equipment might uncover duplicates or items rarely, if ever, used.

6. Prioritize What Brings Joy

Skimming involves quickly selecting the best items from a group and letting go of the rest. Focusing on favorites makes decisions easier and minimizes overthinking.

Instead of agonizing, ask yourself whether an item makes you happy or adds value to your daily life. Anything that doesn’t can probably go. Keep only what has a clear purpose or significant sentimental meaning.

Establishing this habit makes future decluttering faster and less emotional, as you’re training yourself to prioritize quality over quantity.

Examples

  • A homeowner deciding which decorative vases to keep saves only their two favorites.
  • Skimming a packed bookshelf to retain the most cherished volumes leads to fewer regrets later.
  • Clearing out old cookware leaves plenty of space after discarding duplicates and unused specialty tools.

7. Triage Through Choices

Using triage to evaluate belongings can turn decluttering into a systematic, less emotional task. By selecting your least favorite items from groups, you gradually reduce clutter.

This game-like process ensures you eliminate belongings while still keeping those you truly enjoy. It can be repeated until reaching an ideal amount of possessions.

Triage also works for specific collections or overall clutter and makes decision-making simpler without feeling like everything has to go at once.

Examples

  • Parents sorting through old toys pick a few each weekend to donate.
  • A collector assigns one-third of their store of postcards to be given away while keeping the most rare or special ones.
  • Clothing donations increase by picking out the least-favored outfits from wardrobe stacks.

8. Preserve Memories with Photos

Photographing sentimental items allows you to free up physical room without losing your connection to the past. A digital photo album can hold memories just as well as the objects themselves.

Certain big or unwieldy items, like old furniture or keepsakes, may evoke strong emotions. A picture captures their essence while still allowing you to say goodbye.

This strategy is especially helpful for items tied to loved ones, births, milestones, or other life events.

Examples

  • Photographing a child’s first school art project before discarding it to save space.
  • Digital memories of a vintage car enable its sale without guilt.
  • Snapping photos of inherited teacups preserves their memory while passing them to someone else.

9. A New Home for the Things You Release

The act of repurposing, selling, donating, or recycling old belongings allows you to let them go guilt-free and helps others.

When belongings serve someone else’s needs, it feels less like a loss. Consider giving items to friends, family, local charities, or recycling centers. This thoughtful rehoming transforms scaling down into a satisfying experience.

Recycling also provides an eco-friendly option for everyday objects like clothes or electronics. Knowing your efforts help others or the planet softens the process of letting go.

Examples

  • Donating your unused books to a community library benefits more people.
  • Giving a beloved old car to a charity ensures its continued use.
  • Recycling old electronics safely through designated programs preserves natural resources.

Takeaways

  1. Write a clear Scaling Down Mission Statement to focus your decluttering effort.
  2. Use skimming, grouping, and triage methods to simplify decisions and remove excess items objectively.
  3. Take a photo of sentimental belongings if you’re struggling to let them go, and consider donating or recycling items instead of discarding them.

Books like Scaling Down