“If all systems fail, we turn to the federal government. What happens when governments themselves fail or betray us?”
1. The Rebirth of Opulence in Greenwich
Greenwich, Connecticut, once a symbol of restrained wealth, became synonymous with extreme capitalism by the early 2000s. Wealthy financiers and hedge fund managers generated staggering fortunes, causing a seismic shift in values from frugality to excess. This transformation reflected broader economic disparities in the U.S.
As the wealthiest accumulated unimaginable riches, their extraordinary influence didn’t stop at personal luxuries. The richest families in Greenwich wielded power that directly impacted state budgets, underscoring the disproportionate power of the ultra-rich. Meanwhile, hedge funds flourished, multiplying Wall Street's dominance and accelerating the economic divide.
Ethical shifts paralleled this monetary transformation. Restraint and long-term vision gave way to short-term, aggressive profit-seeking. The pursuit of wealth, and the privilege it afforded—elite education, healthcare, and tax advantages—became the yardstick for success, driving a wedge between the ultra-rich and the rest.
Examples
- Hedge fund managers’ profits accounted for 23% of U.S. corporate earnings by 2017.
- Connecticut tax officials monitored the wealthiest taxpayers to balance the state budget.
- By 2007, the top 0.01% of U.S. households controlled $1 of every $17 earned in the entire country.
2. The Republican Party’s Shift Away from Moderation
The moderate face of the Republican Party, once exemplified by Prescott Bush of Greenwich, began fading in the 1960s. Radical ideologies crept in, led by libertarians like J. William Middendorf II and figures such as Barry Goldwater, setting the stage for Rush Limbaugh's vitriolic rhetoric decades later.
The mid-’60s saw a clear rightward shift during Goldwater's presidential run, where voices of moderation like Nelson Rockefeller were drowned out by so-called radical elements. By the 1990s, figures like Limbaugh had begun cementing the Republican party’s anti-government ethos through national media. This movement reached a turning point when Mitt Romney’s 2012 loss led to two competing visions: courting minorities or amplifying the fears of disengaged white voters.
The latter vision prevailed, as leaders realized a populist disruptor could ignite enthusiasm in disillusioned voters. Donald Trump later adopted this approach, aligning his campaign with brash rhetoric and skepticism about the value of government.
Examples
- Prescott Bush criticized Senator Joseph McCarthy for divisive tactics, contrasting modern Republican rhetoric.
- Barry Goldwater’s 1964 nomination symbolized the party’s move to the right.
- Mitt Romney’s 2012 loss prompted an internal GOP split, further encouraging populist appeals.
3. Decline and Displacement in Clarksburg, West Virginia
Once a booming hub fuelled by coal and natural gas, Clarksburg is now a stark reminder of economic decline. As mountaintop removal mining became the dominant extraction method, the local ecosystem and economy suffered, pushing residents into a downward spiral.
Mountaintop removal, though profitable, altered landscapes irreparably while eliminating jobs needed to sustain local livelihoods. Coupled with dwindling resources, Clarksburg's population declined, leaving behind health crises and a diminished tax base. Younger generations left in search of opportunity, creating a feedback loop of decay and neglect.
Meanwhile, the decline of local news sources resulted in disconnected communities and a loss of shared understanding. With fewer reliable local newspapers, residents became more reliant on emotional, nationalized narratives from social media, intensifying feelings of isolation and distrust in institutions.
Examples
- West Virginia lost 18,000 residents between 2007 and 2017, reflecting the exodus of workers.
- Mountaintop removal mining changed the environment while halving the need for mining labor.
- Print advertising revenue collapsed by 71%, leading to the disappearance of local news outlets.
4. Chicago’s History of Racial Segregation
The migration of Black Americans to Chicago during the Great Migration came with hope for a better life but met with systemic barriers, including housing segregation and inferior resources, leading to long-term racial disparities.
Chicago’s white residents colluded to block Black families from moving into their neighborhoods, forcing them into crowded South Side areas. Over time, racist policies compounded this economic confinement, ensuring Black Chicagoans faced educational deficiencies, limited job opportunities, and cycle-after-cycle of disadvantage.
These injustices created profound consequences. Children like Reese, trapped in underfunded schools, often followed paths of drugs, crime, and incarceration. This tragic sequence underscores the enduring barriers faced by Black Americans in Chicago and other segregated cities.
Examples
- Restrictive covenants legally prevented Black families from moving into white neighborhoods.
- Chicago's Black families sent their kids to overcrowded schools with some of the highest dropout rates.
- Reese attended Fenger High, where sports programs were crumbling, and violence overshadowed opportunity.
5. Fear, Immigration, and Trump’s Message
In the years after 9/11, national fear increasingly targeted immigrants, particularly as shifts in demographics made white Americans feel their dominance slipping. Figures like Tom Tancredo and later Donald Trump harnessed these anxieties, promoting falsehoods about immigrant crime and cultural overreach.
Trump, during his 2015 campaign launch, branded immigrants as criminals, seeding his platform in an “us versus them” narrative. Similarly, the escalation of gun culture—marketed as a necessity for individual protection—gave rise to paranoia. Both issues crafted a populist campaign that thrived on division and emotion over fact.
Despite factual evidence disproving immigrant-related crime and falling violence rates, these themes resonated deeply. Trump’s narrative solidified the embrace of fear as a political weapon, further polarizing the nation.
Examples
- Post-2010, immigrant populations grew rapidly, becoming a scapegoat for conservatives.
- Trump accused Syrian refugees of ties to ISIS, fueling fears of terrorism.
- The gun industry connected weapons with safety, played up by NRA advertising.
6. Economic and Social Frustrations Fueled Anger
The American working class faced decades of hardship. Exploitative business practices, polluted environments, and the loss of secure jobs left many embittered. Despite public outrage, leaders often ignored these concerns, exacerbating a growing feeling of neglect.
Mountaintop mining in West Virginia poisoned water supplies and left miners without health coverage. Meanwhile, high-profile failures in the Democratic Party—like Rahm Emanuel’s handling of Laquan McDonald’s shooting—showed systemic neglect in urban communities, fueling mistrust across lines of race and class.
Both groups felt cheated by elites indifferent to their plight. This neglect laid fertile ground for opportunistic leaders to exploit anger and channel grievances toward the “establishment.”
Examples
- West Virginian coal miners lost retiree health care due to Wall Street speculation.
- Laquan McDonald’s case revealed cover-ups at the highest political level in Chicago.
- Polluted land from mining drove health crises, leaving locals with fewer resources.
7. Trump’s Destructive Methods
As president, Trump dismantled federal systems, reduced civil-service payrolls, and attacked institutions like the media. His strategy centered on chaos, disenfranchising individuals and empowering corporate interests to reshape America.
Among other efforts, the 2017 tax cuts redistributed wealth to the top. At the same time, frequent attacks on factual reporting eroded trust in legitimate news sources, sowing confusion across the political spectrum.
Social norms, too, declined under his leadership. His behavior, replicated by supporters, emboldened public figures to openly disregard ethics and civic standards, only heightening divisions within the country.
Examples
- Trump slashed 79,000 government jobs in nine months, creating systemic inefficiencies.
- The $1.5 trillion tax reform handed $48,000 tax breaks to the wealthiest.
- His dismissal of media scrutiny emboldened others to brand truth as “fake news.”
8. Pandemic and Racism Exposed Broken Systems
The COVID-19 pandemic revealed deep-seated inequities, with low-income communities and people of color bearing the brunt. Simultaneously, protests following George Floyd’s death reignited debate over systemic racism, forcing the U.S. to confront uncomfortable truths.
Black Chicagoans, worse affected by COVID-19 due to preexisting disparities, also led major protest efforts. Floyd’s murder became a symbol of injustice, though subsequent protests faced backlash and exploitation by Trump to further racial divides.
Mass unemployment, combined with public health failures, amplified frustrations. These overlapping crises put the inefficiencies and inequities of the U.S. system on full display.
Examples
- Black neighborhoods in Chicago had mortality rates four times higher during COVID-19.
- Unemployment during the early pandemic hit Great Depression-era levels.
- Images from BLM protests were misused to claim widespread violence, despite little evidence.
9. The January 6 Insurrection as a Final Reckoning
The 2020 election built on years of distrust, conspiracy theories, and division, culminating in the storming of the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021. Trump, claiming voter fraud without evidence, encouraged his supporters to fight against an imagined threat.
As rioters broke into the Capitol, the cost of 20 years of social, economic, and political tension became terrifyingly apparent. The insurrection underscored the volatile blend of unresolved societal problems.
Though Biden called for unity during his January 2021 inaugural address, the event serves as a warning: failure to address inequality and misinformation threatens democracy’s survival.
Examples
- Social media rumors fueled right-wing militancy ahead of January 6.
- Trump used the phrase “fight” repeatedly in his speech that day.
- Four rioters and three others died after the insurrection ended.
Takeaways
- Focus on reliable, diverse news sources to remain informed and counter misinformation.
- Actively engage with your local community to rebuild trust and cohesion in divided areas.
- Support policies aimed at equity, education, and representation to address systemic injustices.