Book cover of Mr Unavailable & the Fallback Girl by Natalie Lue

Natalie Lue

Mr Unavailable & the Fallback Girl Summary

Reading time icon16 min readRating icon4.2 (955 ratings)

Why settle for erratic crumbs of affection when you can embrace love that truly fulfills you?

1. Emotional Unavailability Breeds Heartache

Natalie Lue explains how emotionally unavailable men often leave their partners in emotional turmoil. They "blow hot and cold," appearing loving and distant in cycles, leaving their partners confused and doubting themselves. This inconsistency can trap partners in a frustrating loop as they incessantly seek validation.

Such men retreat when the relationship becomes emotionally intimate, only to reappear when their partners distance themselves. Their partners are left questioning what they did wrong, when in reality, this pattern reflects the emotional limits of the unavailable man, not the partner's shortcomings.

By understanding these patterns, women can break free from the confusion and see these behaviors for what they are—a sign to step away and prioritize their own emotional well-being.

Examples

  • A man who lavishly praises you one week, then disappears the next without explanation.
  • Partners who accuse the woman of "dwelling in the past" when questioned about their behavior.
  • Men who often dismiss discussions about the relationship as unnecessary or unimportant.

2. Intense Beginnings Often Mean Quick Endings

Men who move exceptionally fast in relationships can seem romantic but typically aren't ready for long-term commitments. Their whirlwind beginnings often serve to distract partners from spotting deeper issues.

These men appear to commit deeply right away, making future promises they can't or won't keep. While their charm may seem irresistible, their interest usually fades when the relationship begins to demand real emotional work. Their enthusiasm for the "chase" doesn't translate into lasting dedication.

It's crucial to discern between genuine connection and insincere intensity. Fast proposals and over-the-top gestures often mask their inability to sustain healthy long-term relationships.

Examples

  • Someone declaring their love within days of meeting you, only to break it off just as quickly.
  • A man insisting on discussing family plans during the first few dates but avoiding serious talk later.
  • A partner who idealizes the relationship early on but quickly grows distant.

3. Undefined Relationships Keep You Stuck

Mr. Unavailable often avoids labeling relationships, keeping everything in a gray area. This benefits him as he enjoys the perks of a partnership without the responsibilities.

Women stuck in these setups may accept vague arrangements or casual terms, hoping for eventual clarity or commitment. The cycle perpetuates setbacks, as the lack of definition sows insecurity and confusion.

Setting boundaries early is key to avoiding such emotional traps. True partnerships require mutual clarity and commitment, without games.

Examples

  • A man frequently calling just for late-night meetups but avoiding daytime interaction.
  • Excuses for not defining a relationship despite months of dating.
  • Returning after break-ups with promises of change, only to repeat the same patterns.

4. Emotional Manipulation Often Masks Maturity

Natalie warns of men who use their past as a crutch rather than a point of growth. While sharing vulnerabilities might seem healthy, some men exploit it as a way to deflect emotional accountability.

Such individuals may use their "wounds" to justify bad behavior or avoid meeting their partner's emotional needs. By presenting themselves as broken but lovable, they shift the responsibility to their partners to "fix" them.

Real emotional maturity lies in facing and addressing one's shortcomings, not burdening others with them. Partners deserve mutual growth, not emotional evasion.

Examples

  • A man who blames a painful divorce for his inability to commit.
  • Crying during early dates to elicit sympathy rather than offering emotional support in return.
  • Using traumatic life stories to shift focus from current bad behavior.

5. Understanding Yourself Is More Important Than Understanding Him

Rather than obsessing over why Mr. Unavailable behaves the way he does, Natalie suggests turning the focus inward. Women often waste time trying to "fix" their partners but neglect their own well-being and needs.

Taking a step back and understanding what attracts you to unavailable men is vital. Many people repeat unhealthy patterns learned from childhood, such as relationships witnessed with parents or messages absorbed from society.

Rediscovering your own priorities and values allows you to break free from these patterns and create space for healthier relationships.

Examples

  • Repeatedly seeking men similar to emotionally distant parental figures.
  • Overcommitting to "fix" damaged partners despite their unwillingness to change.
  • Accepting subpar treatment due to fear of being alone.

6. The Fallback Girl: A Common Archetype

Natalie identifies a repeated cycle of women, known as Fallback Girls, who enable Mr. Unavailable's bad behavior. These women often excuse poor behavior, blame themselves, or cling to relationships without commitment.

Fallback Girls come in many forms—such as "Yo-yo Girls" tolerating on-and-off relationships or "Buffer Girls" caught between a man and his ex-partner. Other versions include the "Florence" who tries to heal damaged men or "Floggers" sacrificing happiness in an emotionally barren marriage.

Recognizing which behaviors align with these patterns allows women to break free and demand more for themselves.

Examples

  • Staying in on-off relationships, hoping for a turnaround.
  • Entering relationships with married men who promise future commitment.
  • Remaining in loveless marriages for the sake of appearances or martyrdom.

7. Avoiding Emotionally Available Men Reflects Emotional Blocks

Enmeshed in chasing unavailable partners, many women unknowingly shut themselves off from emotionally available men. These distractions leave no room for healthy, loving partnerships to grow.

Emotional unavailability can infect both partners—it’s often easier to control the narrative with an uninterested partner than to be vulnerable in a genuine one. Recognizing this tendency is vital in seeking lasting, fulfilling love.

Shifting focus from unavailable men to personal growth allows you to embrace and reciprocate true affection when it appears.

Examples

  • Ignoring a kind, supportive man as "too nice" while pursuing more distant individuals.
  • Fearing intimacy and unconsciously gravitating toward relationships with no future.
  • Over-investing in "saving" a damaged partner instead of fostering mutual love.

8. Boundary Setting Paves the Way to Healthy Love

A successful relationship starts with clear boundaries that uphold your emotional health. Knowing your values and boundaries helps control how much you're willing to tolerate and avoid toxic entanglements.

Sharing these boundaries early creates healthier dynamics. It also ensures you’ll attract someone who respects what’s important to you. Good relationships feel empowering rather than draining.

Strong boundaries protect against over-accommodation and restore self-trust. Learning to listen to your instincts also strengthens decision-making in relationships.

Examples

  • Refusing to accept infidelity when monogamy is a non-negotiable value.
  • Expressing discomfort when a partner repeatedly cancels plans.
  • Walking away when red flags appear, rather than dismissing them.

9. A Fulfilling Life Prepares You for Fulfilling Relationships

Natalie highlights the importance of creating a joyful, well-rounded life outside of relationships. A healthy partnership isn’t about finding someone to "complete" you but sharing your happiness and growth.

Reconnect with passions, strengthen friendships, and explore new interests. By doing so, you become more confident and independent, avoiding the trap of leaning on relationships alone for fulfillment.

This personal balance increases the likelihood of attracting balanced, loving partnerships.

Examples

  • Joining a book club or learning a new language to expand your social circles.
  • Traveling solo to rediscover your independence.
  • Strengthening friendships to create a strong support network beyond romantic ties.

Takeaways

  1. Create clear boundaries by identifying your core values and communicating them early in relationships.
  2. Pause unhealthy cycles by recognizing patterns, such as chasing unavailable men, and actively choosing new approaches to dating.
  3. Focus on personal growth and joy, ensuring you are emotionally fulfilled and ready for a healthy relationship.

Books like Mr Unavailable & the Fallback Girl